Rockford Fosgate vs Kicker Subwoofers

If you’ve gone shopping for a new car subwoofer or amplifiers in the last, oh, decade, I am sure you have come across two behemoth brands, Rockford Fosgate and Kicker. They’re inescapable, omnipresent in any car audio store, and that’s no coincidence There are several reasons for their strong market presence.

To start with, both manufacturers make excellent subwoofers and amplifiers with superb technology that is long lasting and stable. Rockford Fosgate vs Kicker is a neck in neck battle. Choosing between them is a question of price and what specifications meet your unique needs. We pit Rockford Fosgate vs. Kicker, comparing a few subs from each, to see how the two car audio brands stack up.

This post is going to check out what’s the real story of Kicker vs. Rockford Fosgate to help you in deciding which one is right for you!

Rockford Fosgate vs Kicker

The Witness: Rockford Fosgate

Rockford Fosgate vs Kicker subwoofersIn this corner, we’ve got Rockford Fosgate subwoofers! which seem to be well-liked. RF subwoofers are some of the best selling car subwoofers on the market.

Rockford Fosgate offers a wide range of subwoofers from the entry-level Prime and Punch subs right up to the high performance, expensive Power subwoofers. For the purpose of this article we’ll be focusing on Punch subwoofers since they represent the perfect mix of power and price.

Punch series subwoofers come in various designs and sizes. As their name implies, these subwoofers sound punchy. They’re designed to produce enough bass to satisfy almost anyone. Punch components will give you impressive sound that’ll stand out in a crowd. They use an advanced technology that yields a relatively larger woofer cone of up to 25% than competing models of the same size. To us, a larger woofer cone means a wide dispersion, and more powerful bass.

In terms of power handling, Rockford Fosgate Punch subwoofers can handle a decent amount of power on continuous basis. This means, you can push them a lot harder without damaging them. The downside, however, is that they’re a bit lacking in terms of sensitivity. Therefore, you’ll need a powerful amplifier to drive these subs.

Sensitivity rating refers to how well a speakers can convert power into volume. For every 3dB increase in sensitivity, only half the power is required to create the same volume output. In other words, subwoofers with high sensitivity rating require less power to produce the same volume than subs with low sensitivity rating.

We’ve also found that while the bass output that these subwoofers produce is remarkably enough to satisfy anyone, it’s a bit lacking in terms of quality. I mean the bass is there, but it’s not well-defined and well-rounded as some high-end subwoofers we’ve come across.

ROCKFORD FOSGATE P3D2-12 ReviewROCKFORD FOSGATE P3D2-12 Review

The P3D2-12 is one of RF’s best selling 12 inch car subwoofer. This 2-Ohm dual voice coil subwoofer can handle up to 600 watts on continuous basis. It is the best performing Rockford Fosgate Punch series subwoofer.

The P3D2-12 subwoofer is designed for deeper, louder bass. It features a rigid anodized aluminum cone that stays rigid through heavy play,  while staying responsive. Rockford Fosgate uses a new technique to attach the oversized rubber surround to the cone that increases available cone area up to 25%, so this sub can produce even bigger bass.

This subwoofer features multiple technologies that make a solid and great woofer including double snacked magnets that allow it to really hit hard, as well as vast surround which increases the effective radiating cone area and maximum output.

All in all, the P3D2-12 is a great all-around subwoofer. It’s great for those who are looking for a well-engineered subwoofer with decent bass output that doesn’t break the bank.

Rockford Fosgate P3D2-12 Specifications
  • Size : 12″
  • Sensitivity    : 85 dB
  • Power-handling 
    • Peak   : 1200 watts
    • RMS    : 300 – 600 watts
  • Frequency response : 27-250 Hz
  • Top-mount depth : 6-11/16″

The Witness: Kicker

Kicker L7 series subwoofersKicker offers a wide range of car subwoofers for every purpose. For the purpose of this article, we’ll be focusing on the Comp Series subwoofers that Kicker says to be the best bang for your buck.

Comp series subs are Kicker’s best selling subwoofers probably because they’re in more of a low-mid price range. Kicker Comp series subwoofers come in various designs (single and dual voice coils) and sizes (from 8″ to 15″). They’re best suited for those looking to add some bass to their car audio system without spending a ton of cash.

Kicker subwoofers are designed to handle a decent amount of power. The trick to making these subs sound great is to put them in a medium to large-sized enclosure (sealed OR ported) and most importantly to not overpower them. 150 – 250 watts RMS is all you need. If you’re more into SPL competition, look for L7 series subwoofers. They’re built with that in mind. L7 subwoofers are pretty expensive and require a ton of power, and may drain on your car’s electrical system, so you’ll need to upgrade it or at the very least use a car audio capacitor.

So, whether you’re looking for a budget-friendly subwoofer, shallow mount subwoofer, or SPL subwoofer, Kicker has got you covered.

Kicker 10C124 12 inch subwoofer ReviewKicker 10C124 Review

The 10C124 is one of kicker’s best selling 12″ inch subwoofer. It features a flex-resistant polypropylene woofer cone with 360-degree back bracing for hard-hitting lows without distortion. Its strong motor structure, ribbed foam surround, double stitching and extensive venting ensure long-lasting performance, while its tough steel basket provides a reliable foundation for big bass.

This 12″ inch subwoofer sports a sensitivity rating of 88 dB. It can handle up to 150 watts RMS. It can be mounted in either a ported or sealed enclosure. It’s also suitable for free-air applications.

Kicker 10C124 Specifications
  • Size : 12″
  • Sensitivity    : 88 dB
  • Power-handling 
    • Peak   :   300 watts
    • RMS    :  50 – 150 watts
  • Frequency response :  27 – 500 Hz
  • Top-mount depth : 5-3/4″

The Verdict

Here at Stereochamp, we are constantly being asked to shed some light on the difference between Rockford Fosgate and Kicker subwoofers, and which is better. This can be very difficult to answer. So instead of asking about which subwoofers are better – Kicker’s or Rockford Fosgate’s – It’s better to ask which one is best suited for your application.

The bottom line is that no matter what you’re looking for in a subwoofer, Rockford Fosgate and Kicker have divided up the pie rather well, and between the two, there’s something for almost everyone.